Man, I really wanted to like this pod but the dude is so boring that he puts himself to sleep! Maybe I caught an off day…but get some rest homie!

Great information. The “mmmmm hmmmm….yep” every 8 seconds is very distracting.

Great show guys! At the risk of trashing your predecessors, it’s nice to hear great baseball analysis instead of video game reviews. Keep up the great work!

Very entertaining look at the guards minor league system ! Well done and a fun listen. Love the poem At end of each pod :)

I love the content but you guys like, trail off and say stuff under your breath at the end of almost every sentence it seems. I think you are trying to be funny and ironic/sarcastic but it’s really just very distracting. Otherwise great and informative content.

Great pod. Best part of my week when this comes out. The hosts are funny, insightful, and entertaining

Love listening to these guy’s talk Guard’s baseball. Win lose whatever. Ready for ‘22. Never know what can happen I guess.

These guys offer nothing insightful. Their articles refuse to use the name of the team. Newsflash the team is still called the Indians. Every sentence in their articles begin with Cleveland and just comes off as repetitive. Just get your news from somewhere else.

Please for the love of God please do not bring the name “spiders” to popularity... I PROMISE YOU IT STINKS!!

Great info as long as keeping it lighthearted

Like others have reviewed, I want to like these guys, b/c they sometimes provide good insight to Indians situations. Unfortunately, there is too much voice inflection (talk too low at times, so cannot be heard), talk too fast at times (hard too understand), and allow their cornball personalities to steal time away from nuggets of good discussion. Hoping to hear improvement or it may be time for me to move on.

Period.

I guess swearing emphasis the point they try to make. Telling potential sponsors you’ll say you will use their product...because that’s what others do??? Tough sell

I so much want to like these guys, but they make it difficult. When they try, they can be informative. But most of the time they try to cute with bad jokes and foul language. They could accomplish much more. Tribe fans deserve better.

These guys seem to be very analytics driven, well informed, and up to date on the farm system and current roster. However, I have 2 agree with two takes in these reviews. Merritt is a tough, tough listen. The comically deep voice, random rants, and failed attempts at humor really drag this down. Also, this could be a solid, tight half hour podcast, instead it’s an hour long of info sprinkled with meandering side tracks and attempts at “humor”. Close to being a great pod, but equally close to being garbage.

These guys tell it like it is without drama. So great at assessing the state of the Indians, I know exactly where things stand in Cleveland and the rest of the MLB. Keep it up!

I love you guys imparting info about the Tribe, but keeps me engaged with your humor and totally mixed metaphors. Keep up the good work guys! Go Tribe! #RallyTogether

The not-sac-bunting of podcasts

Tried this pod for a month or so, and just didn’t enjoy it. Merritt Rohlfing is a tough listen. Tries to be funny too often and talks about odd topics that have no substance (Lindor having pine tar on his helmet). They do give good info on Tribe farm system but overall not a great listen.

Every week, I look forward to a new episode. Best Tribe podcast from the best Tribe site. I can always count on them to make me laugh, and I appreciate that so incredibly much. I swore I submitted a review once, so hopefully this one makes it through. Thanks, guys!

The podcast made my hourly drive to work quick and profanity free. I look forward to future podcasts. Great to keep informed about the Tribe!

Great podcast guys, the best part is how consistently it comes out every week.

You can do just as well by downloading AtBat - read the articles and listen to the games live - and reading the Plain Dealer’s coverage on print or online. This is just guys talking. I admire their spirit and stick-to-it-iveness but there’s nothing outstanding here. If you really want a Indians podcast just listen to the Cleveland.com one. ——— The above was written partly in response to the hand-wringing about Yandy Diaz and how nobody appreciates him and how Melky Cabrera shouldn’t be playing. Well...a) now Encarnacion is back and they didn’t send Diaz down (he even started last night) and b) Cabrera has hit a bunch of home runs. So maybe just relax a little? :) ——— Sep. 20 ... Diaz strikes out with the bases loaded, and then Cabrera walks on a 9-pitch at bat. The Melk-man has played good defense AND hit the ball extremely well, in all kinds of different situations. You guys owe him an apology.

If you’re a Tribe Fan, it’s a must listen! Let’s Go Tribe!

Good stuff, guys. The format has really improved over time which is no surprise. Thanks for doing this.

One of my favorite podcasts to listen to each week. The Let's Talk Tribe crew is informative, intelligent and hilarious. You won't be disappointed.

My favorite Indians podcast by far, I look forward to, not Jason and Matt's take on the Tribe every week, but also some of the great guests they bring on to add depth to their analysis. The production could use a little polishing (volume levels) but that is all that is holding me back from giving it five stars.